The Problems with Proof-texting - Deeper Christian
So what is proof-texting? Webster defines proof-texting as taking isolated quotes (ie: a text) and establishing a position that may not be the author’s original intent. About a year ago I was teaching Saturation Bible Study to the teens at my church. To illustrate proof-texting I said, “Here, let me randomly flip open the Bible, read a ...
Images
The Perils of Proof-Texting and How to Avoid Them - STR
Is it possible one or more of the proof-texts have more than one reasonable meaning? If so, then choosing one of the alternate meanings could remove the apparent contradiction. If one verse seems completely inflexible (univocal, or unequivocal), then adapt the more flexible verse (the equivocal one) to bring harmony. Let me give you an example.
The Pitfalls of Proof-Texting: The Dangers of Selective Scripture Use
These examples demonstrate how proof-texting involves isolating specific verses and using them to support a particular viewpoint, often disregarding their original context and the broader teachings of Scripture. It is important to consider the Bible's intent, context, and overall teachings to avoid misinterpretation and ensure a more accurate ...
What Is Proof Texting? - Bible Study
Proof texting can easily lead to wrong conclusions regarding what is the truth of God. An argument or doctrinal stand that relies heavily on proof passages is ultimately considered weak. In fact, those who preach and teach others based on such special passages in Scripture are generally viewed negatively by true Biblical scholars and those who ...
What is Proof Texting? - Len Joson
Examples of Proof Texts. One good example of proof texting is that of people quoting John 6:44 to explain that only a few will be saved and that God is setting limits to salvation. This verse is quoted to support a view that God has already decided who will be saved and it’s not everybody. For an explanation on this topic, please visit this link.
The Problem with Proof-Texting the Bible - by Wes McAdams
What is proof-texting is? Why is it problematic? And how can we all approach Scripture with greater humility and accuracy. ... Examples like Philippians 4:13, Jeremiah 29:11, and Hebrews 10:25 highlight how verses are often misused. The episode encourages readers to move beyond shallow interpretations and engage deeply with the broader biblical ...
Are you using that proof text well…or are you proof-texting? - CCEF
More significantly, you will encounter countless subtler examples of proof-texting in the negative sense—whenever Scripture is misinterpreted or misused. For example, Genesis 1–2 describes God’s foundational call to fruitful, meaningful work and to fruitful oneness in marriage. It presumes that human beings are active agents.
What is Proof-Texting? (with picture) - Language Humanities
Proof-texting is generally disdained by experts as an attempt to deceive a gullible audience, and is often considered a logical fallacy of authoritarian bias. In a typical proof-text, a person will use a quote, often a Biblical verse, as evidence for their related argument. ... For example, if a person was arguing that it is fine to disobey ...
Ten Twisted Scriptures:Ten Twisted Scriptures
it’s an excellent illustration of the dangers of proof-texting—that is, “proving” one’s pet doctrine by quoting one or more Bible passages, usually out of context. “A text, out of context, is a pretext.” This saying is familiar to most theology students, or any serious student of literature, for that mat-ter.
Proof texting - Theopedia
Proof texting. Proof texting is the method by which a person appeals to a biblical text to prove or justify a theological position without regard for the context of the passage they are citing. At its worst, for example, "theologian A claims to have a more 'biblical' theology than theologian B, based upon counting up verse in parentheses (on a random page from each work) and claiming to have ...
Prooftext - Wikipedia
In biblical interpretation, a proof text is a passage of scripture presented as proof for a theological doctrine, belief, or principle. [1] Prooftexting (sometimes "proof-texting" or "proof texting") is the practice of using quotations from a document, either for the purpose of exegesis, or to establish a proposition in eisegesis (introducing one's own presuppositions, agendas, or biases).
On Proof-Texting - Reformed Journal
I have always understood the trouble with proof-texting as, using Scripture to prove MY point, more than it is Scripture’s point. “Spare the rod, spoil the child” as a way to justify corporal punishment (use of physical force to discipline) as an example. Proof-texting becomes zingers when the focus is on me way more than on Scripture.
The Art and Practice of Biblical Proof-Texting – Adventist Today
The proof text method of biblical interpretation has a long and varied history that reaches back to biblical times and before. One well-known key text that was applied by first Christians to Jesus’ life is Hosea 11:1, “Out of Egypt have I called my son” (Matthew 2:15). ... (for example, John 7:5a). I’ve pondered what penalty might ...
Decontextualising: Prooftexting - biblestudylessons.net
An example is when Jesus helped the lepers, "And when he saw [them], he said unto them, Go shew yourselves unto the priests" (Luke 17:14). This was a specific command to Jews. given before the cross and the validation of the New Covenant. ... "Proof-texting ignores the context of the passage or chapter in which the particular verse is located ...
The Other Side Of “Proof-Texting” | Robert C. Crosby
The oft-cited old adage concerning “proof-texting” is: “A text without a context is a pretext for a proof text.” Allen and Swain cite “three primary charges” leveled by the critics of ...
What About Proof Texting? - BIBLE CROSSFIRE
Jesus constantly "proof texted." You probably remember Jesus using three separate proof texts to reply to the devil’s three temptations of Him in Matt 4:1-11.Also consider the example of when the Sadducees argued "that there is no resurrection" (after life) in Matt 22:23ff.
Why Proof Texting Makes For Bad Theology - Kainos Project
If we're proof texting verses where the author's intent doesn't actually support our point, then we're missing the point. Share on X Not Every Decision or Statement Needs a Proof Text. Most of the time when we end up proof texting a verse or passage apart from its context or authorial intent, it isn’t because we’re trying to do anything ...
Were the Westminster Theologians “Proof-texting”? - Reformedish
Now, as I was saying, proof-texting is often brought up in discussions as a prime example of decontextualized readings–readings that irresponsibly ignore the literary and historical setting of the text. As the popular saying goes, “a text without a context is a pretext for a proof text.”
Five Examples of Proofreading - Nick Higham
Here is an extract from the proofs of my recent SIAM Review paper (with Natasa Strabic and Vedran Sego) Restoring Definiteness via Shrinking, with an Application to Correlation Matrices with a Fixed Block: We noticed that the word “how” appears at the end of a line four times within seven lines—an unfortunate coincidence.